The AR-15 platform's enduring popularity stems from its modularity and adaptability. While modern upgrades are constantly emerging, a significant segment of shooters maintains a fondness for the classic aesthetic and functionality of the carry handle upper receiver. This detailed guide explores the benefits, drawbacks, and nuances of choosing a carry handle AR-15 upper for your build.
Understanding the Carry Handle Upper
The carry handle upper receiver is a defining feature of early AR-15 rifles. Instead of a separate rear sight, the carry handle integrates the rear sight directly into the upper receiver. This design provides a sturdy, integral sighting system, contributing to the rifle's overall robustness.
Key Advantages of a Carry Handle AR-15 Upper:
-
Robustness and Durability: The integrated carry handle design creates a single, solid unit, enhancing the overall strength and rigidity of the upper receiver. This is particularly advantageous in harsh conditions or during rigorous use.
-
Classic Aesthetic: For many shooters, the carry handle upper evokes a sense of nostalgia and represents a classic, timeless design. Its distinctive look sets it apart from more modern, Picatinny-railed uppers.
-
Simplified Sighting System: The integrated carry handle eliminates the need for separate rear sight installation, simplifying the build process and reducing potential compatibility issues.
-
Cost-Effectiveness (Sometimes): In some cases, a complete carry handle upper receiver can be a more cost-effective option than purchasing a standard upper and a separate high-quality rear sight.
Potential Drawbacks:
-
Limited Mounting Options: The absence of a Picatinny rail on top of the carry handle restricts the mounting options for optics like red dot sights or scopes. While some aftermarket solutions exist, they often compromise the sleek profile.
-
Weight: The integrated carry handle adds a noticeable amount of weight compared to a standard flattop upper.
-
Co-witnessing Challenges: Achieving proper co-witnessing with a magnified optic and iron sights can be difficult or impossible without significant modifications.
-
Height Over Bore: The height of the carry handle can impact cheek weld and overall shooting comfort, especially for shooters with shorter necks or when using certain stock configurations.
Choosing the Right Carry Handle Upper: Factors to Consider
Selecting a carry handle upper requires careful consideration of several factors:
1. Material and Manufacturing Quality:
- Forged vs. Cast: Forged uppers are generally considered more durable and resistant to stress than cast uppers. Look for reputable manufacturers who utilize high-quality materials and precise manufacturing techniques.
2. Sight Quality:
The quality of the integrated rear sight is critical. Ensure that the sight is properly adjusted, durable, and offers clear and precise aiming. Look for windage and elevation adjustments for accurate zeroing.
3. Finish:
A durable finish is crucial for protecting the upper receiver from the elements and wear and tear. Anodized finishes are commonly used and provide excellent corrosion resistance.
Modern Alternatives and Adaptations:
While traditional carry handles offer a classic feel, some modern manufacturers offer hybrid designs. These might incorporate a Picatinny rail section alongside the carry handle, offering greater versatility.
Conclusion:
Carry handle AR-15 upper receivers offer a unique blend of classic aesthetics, robust construction, and simplified sighting systems. While they may present some limitations in terms of mounting options and weight, they remain a popular choice among enthusiasts who value reliability and the traditional look of early AR-15 rifles. Careful consideration of the advantages, drawbacks, and individual needs is crucial in determining if a carry handle upper is the right choice for your next AR-15 build.
